John Vonderlin: 1896: No Hope for the Colombia Shipwreck

Story by John Vonderlin

Email John: benloudman@sbcglobal.net

Hi June,

Here’s another Colombia shipwreck newspaper story to add to the others you have in your large “Shipwreck” folder. Thanks to the improvements in the Search function on the California Newspaper Archive, many new illustrations are showing up during searches.  I’ve attached the one that accompanied this story, as well as two others from other stories about the Colombia, from about the same time. It’s interesting to compare the drawings with the actual photograph of the Colombia you have in the folder. This article appeared in “The San Francisco Call,” issue of July, 6, 1896. Enjoy. John

NO HOPE FOR THE COLOMBIA,
Each Swell Churns the Vessel on Jagged Rocks.
BORNE IN TOWARD THE SHORE.
Water Fills the Forward Hold to a Level With the Hatchways.
CAPTAIN CLARK BLAMED FOR
THE DISASTER.
Kept the Vessel Moving at Thirteen
Knots an Hour in the Fog.
PESCADERO, Cal., July 15.— The Pacific Mail steamship Colombia is thumping the life out of herself and her master is walking her trembling deck trying to explain why he ran his ship thirteen knots an hour in a fog almost as dense as milk. But whatever reason Captain Clark may give for plunging ahead at high speed through a vapor-hidden sea, the Colombia wallows heavily on the rocks a few hundred yards to the southward of Pigeon Point. The reef is gnawing great holes in her good steel hulk, and to and fro down in the forehold the waves rise and fall. She struck first on the port bow and the jagged rocks rent her cruelly there; then the wounded craft, pushed ahead by a 13-knot force, went farther on to the sharp points, and the ground swell, with its lifting and sinking, is completing her undoing. Every time she lets down on the cluster of rocks the shattered plates in her bottom bend and break. She groans as she rolls in ber bed and the grinding of the reef that is destroying her resounds weird and uncanny through her compartments. This was a beautiful, calm, sunny day and the doomed Colombia appeared to
rest safely on a quiet sea. She went ashore at low water and her fore hold, with fifteen to eighteen feet of water in it, holds her bow down on the rocks when the rising tide elevates her stern. Still the bow lifts somewhat on the swell — just enough to let the forward part of the steamer’s hull pound the plates out of her, and the strokes can be heard ashore through the quiet air. When the Colombia struck she was headed northward, directly for San Francisco. Captain Clark was hurrying. He had been speeding up the coast from Acapulco, his last port, and was trying to make a record with the new Pacific Mail steamer that came out to take the lost Colima’s place. He was already two days ahead of time and was still doing well, so he was hugging the points of land and no seagrass was growing under his keel — hence the thirteen knots an hour in a dense fog. Within 200 yards of a field of hay, cut and in stacks, lies this courser of the seas, now helpless on the shore. Spectators from all the country around dotted the shore to-day and watched her roll and grind. Some brought their lunch-baskets and made a picnic of a disaster. The Colombia pitches but little, as her bow is hard on the rocks, but every time a swell strikes her she comes down aft with a force that momentarily threatens not only to stave her in but to break her in two. Sometimes she rolls over at an angle of 45 degrees, and comes back onto the rocks with a force and suddenness that threatens to snap her spars. That was a danger momentarily threatened this forenoon. Captain Clark stood on the starboard side of the forward deck this morning when she turned over further than usual and came back with a thud and a crash.
“That’s a hard one,” he said curtly, “and they’re getting bigger. She won’t last long if they get much worse.”
The Colombia lies in a little bay, with the Pigeon Point lighthouse high above her on a point about a quarter of a mile to the north. When there is a blow outside the waves house-high chase each other into this bay. If a storm should come up outside the Colombia would be tossed up and down on the rocks so that there would not be enough left of her in twelve aours for use as scrapiron. This is what the ship’s officers are afraid of. Even if the weather continues calm, which it is likely to do at this ume of year, the officers
do not believe the Colombia can be saved. They try to put a cheerful face on the situation, but it is an effort to do so. When asked separately by a Call representative whether it would be possible to save the vessel three of the ship’s officers said “I do not think so.” Another said, laconically, “You tell us how.” When asked this morning how he felt Captain Clark replied, “Well, I’m still on deck,” and then the captain caught hold of a rope to steady himself as the ship lurched toward the land.

Every swell that strikes the Colombia works her further in shore, inch by inch and foot by foot. By this time to-morrow, if the present rate of progress keeps up, it will be possible to pitch hay down on to her decks from the fields above. To such ignoble possibility may a noble ship come in her great helplessness.
Up to noon to-day there was water in only one compartment forward. There is no water aft, though the rocks are expected almost with each roll to punch a hole into her and let in the sea. The fires under her boilers were out this morning. The reason for this was stated by one of the engineers to be to save coal. Most of the ship’s coal is in the forward compartment, and the bulkhead next to it is full of rolling water and floating and pitching cargo. It could be plainly seen through the open hatch. During a half-hour this morning the water in this compartment raised two feet, until it was flush with the deck, and broken boxes and packages of merchandise were almost thrown over the sides of the hatch as back and forth she rocked.
Captain Clark said this afternoon if the weather was favorable he intended to drop his anchors and try to work the Colombia’s stern around so that she would float with only her prow on the sand and rocks. The tug Vigilant is lying about a half mile out to sea for this purpose or any other service she may be able to render the stranded ship. The tug Reliance lay out to sea all forenoon, but left at 12 o’clock for San Francisco with Mrs. Strand, the stewardess of the Colombia, several attaches of the ship and other passengers. Mrs. Strand waved a sad farewell to her shipmates as she left for the tug in one of the ship’s boats. Captain Metcalf, an underwriter’s agent, took charge of the stranded steamer. The Colombia’s crew, from the captain down, will remain with her until ordered to leave. All the boats are tied alongside, and during the night a big, white lifeboat from the life-saving station at Fort Point came down and dropped anchor between
the ship and the shore. This it could easily do, as the Colombia rolls in less than four fathoms of water. The figures on her bow show twenty-three feet, while her stern is comparatively high up. As the ship lies at present there is no danger to the lives of those aboard, but if a blow should come up and the swells run high the ship’s boats would be very necessary. Work aboard the Colombia to-day indicates her abandonment, as much, if not more, than it does anything else. She is being diligently lightered of her cargo, and everything aboard is being racked up, preparatory to removal, from lamp globes to the ship’s stores. The steward said it
might be necessary to remove them in a hurry, and they wanted to put them into shape. This is altogether probable. It will only take enough water to roll the ship over and leave her bottom-up in the breakers.
The steam schooners, Newsboy and Jewel, are lying by the Colombia. The Newsboy was busy hoisting tons of coffee by the sack out of the Colombia’s hold and dropping it into her own. The steam winch got no rest since early in the morning. The Jewel lies out a way, awaiting her turn. She will tie up alongside when the Newsboy is loaded. The latter will try and take all the coffee and the Jewel the remainder of the cargo, which is general merchandise and baggage. Most of the cargo will be taken out undamaged, as up. to this evening there was water in the compartment forward only. The fishermen and farmers in the vicinity of Pigeon Point may have had a famine for many years, as to Central American fruit, but they are having a feast now. The fisherman’s boat in which a Call representative was rowed out to the wreck from Lighthouse Point this morning was nearly half filled with Central American limes. The enterprising boatman had picked them up from the surf and from the water near the ship. They were a part of the Colombia’s burst cargo. Thousands of the yellow fruit floated in the sea. Captain Clark was rather uncommunicative
this morning on the subject of shipwrecks. He answered questions in monosyllables instead of sentences. The captain simply reiterated that he mistook the New Years Island fog whistle for the Pigeon Point fog whistle, and that is about all there is to it, and about all he had to say. When he heard the Pigeon Point whistle he believed it was the toot of another vessel and changed his course to starboard. Five minutes later the Colombia was crunching in among the rocks. If the rocks had not stopped her in another half minute she would have bad her nose buried in the sand of the beach. Third Officer Thompson, who was on watch on the bridge when the Colombia struck, told the best story of how it happened. ‘We had passed New Years Island light and thought it was Pigeon Point,” he said. “The captain was on the bridge with me. We were listening for the fog signals and did not hear any, after passing New Years, until we were about where we stand now. Then we heard two short whistles, close together, and thought it was another vessel. The captain commanded ‘Hard a-starboard!” and down went the wheel hard a-starboard. In about five minutes she struck. She went on easy, but we could hear her crunching on the rocks. The fog was so thick it could be scooped up with a shovel. I was on the bridge and I couldn’t see the bow of the ship. You can almost throw a line ashore now, but we could not see the shore. I saw breakers and shouted ‘Breakers ahead !’ but it was too late then.” “Do you think the ship can be saved?” “I fear not,” he replied. The vessel rocked and rolled and pounded against the bottom while this conversation took place. Third Officer Thompson had to use his best sea legs to keep on his feet. “Isn’t there danger of her snapping a spar?” was asked. “That’s what I’m looking out for,” replied Ship’s Surgeon Arberry. “That Pigeon Point whistle ought to be changed,” resumed Third Officer Thompson. “It sounds too much like a steamer. It was very low and the instant we heard it we went to starboard to get out of the way. The whistles ought to be longer or shorter or more of them.” Captain James Marner is the keeper of the Pigeon Point light station. He has been there eight years. Captain Marner is a typical lighthouse-keeper. He has the breeze of the sea in his jovial air. In regard to the criticism of his fog signals, he said : “The fog signals are fixed by the Government. My duty is to see that they are carried out and the whistles blown. I blew my whistles from 11 :35 o’clock on the night of the 13th to 12:25 o’clock on the afternoon of the 14th, when the fog lifted. I heard the ship go on the rocks. The noise could be heard plainly up here. I thought at first she was the Madrona, but when the fog raised I saw a big black ship. My signal is a whistle of four seconds’ duration, an interval of seven seconds, another blast of four seconds and then an interval of forty-five seconds and then repeat. That of the New Years  Island light is a blast of ten seconds’ duration, an interval of fifty seconds and repeat. ‘Now, the captain of the Colombia has nobody but himself to blame,” continued Captain Marner. “He has his charts, maps and books to tell him where he is, and I do not see how he came to get in so close. His books would have told him which was the Pigeon Point light. But I cannot talk much. Captain Clark will be examined in the City, and I will be subpenaed.” J. C. Williamson, a merchant of Pescadero, says the Colombia is the fifth vessel to go ashore in the six miles between Pigeon Point and New Years Island. The ship Sir John Franklin was the first to go ashore. This was in 1868, and seventeen lives were lost. A tornbstone on the island marks the disaster. The bark Carrier was wrecked on that treacherous shore in 1869. She was coal-laden, and twenty-one lives were lost. In 1857 the ship Courier was wrecked on the point. The ship Hellespont was wrecked in 1870, in almost the same spot as the Colombia. At 10 o’clock to-night the Colombia was lying somewhat easier. She did not pound so hard, and that change in her condition, if it is permanent, may prove her salvation in the event that there is no rough weather. She seems to have slipped around into an easier berth on the sand, but she still rolls badly. This afternoon at low tide the steam-schooners were extremely cautious in approaching her and lying alongside. The swell was heavier, and the waterlogged Colombia reeled fearfully. The Newsboy anchored as far away as she could without interrupting the work of lightening. Her sides were protected by bales of hay to prevent the Colombia from crushing’ them in. Frequently the steamship on her backward reel would strike the schooner a hard blow, but the hay prevented damage, though the concussion several times knocked the men off their feet. The work of lightening continued tonight, small boats carrying the cargo from tbe ship to the schooners which were anchored a considerable distance away. About all the coffee is unloaded, but there  are tons and tons of New York merchandise yet to come out. Underwriters’ Agent Metcalfe says that further salvage of the cargo will necessitate the use of two scow schooners, and he will send to San Francisco for them. The plan and the hope of the underwriters and of Captain Clark is to take out all of the cargo as speedily as possible, then pull the Colombia off the rocks and tow her to San Francisco. This is considered possible if she is not stove in more and water does not get in any compartment other than the one forward. The Colombia to-night lay in the inky blackness of the little bay, a spectacle of light. Her donkey-engine was running, and the electric light plant was in full blast. The lights twinkled in the darkness as she rolled first over toward the land and then back toward the open sea. Hundreds of feet above the lighthouse stood, flashing a warning of the Colombia’s fate to the other vessels, which could be seen with their red, green and white lights, passing safely by on the sea’s highway.

Comments off

John Vonderlin: Peninsula Farms

Story by John Vonderlin

Email John: benloudman@sbcglobal.net

Hi June,
If I remember right, Peninsula Farms, bought Coburn’s land after he died. Do you know much about them? This ad was in the June 17th, 1922, “Pacific Rural Press.” Enjoy. John
ARTICHOKE LANDS FOR LEASE — Ranches of any size to suit experienced artichoke growers for lease on cash or share basis. Proven soil, climate, and plenty of water. Ranches available now. Some with improvements on producing plantations and others with land and water only. Apply: Peninsula Farms Co., Pescadero, Calif. This company has also good feed and water for 3 to 6 thousand head of sheep for the next 6 months, and will entertain offers for the disposal of it. IRRIGATED LAND ON GOOD TERMS— You can’t beat the terms we offer.

Comments off

John Vonderlin: 1905: Want a Bank in Pescadero?

Story by John Vonderlin

Email John: benloudman@sbcglobal.net

Hi June,
This article mentioning the “rivalry” between Pescadero, and Half Moon Bay, was in the August 17th, 1905, issue of the “San Francisco Call.” Who won the competition anyway? And whatever happened to this bank? It is mentioned only once in the old newspapers, that being this article.
With a little research, I see Mr. Oliver, the bank’s financier, was down in L.A., wheeling and dealing real estate, his profession, by March, 1906. In 1908, he was being sued for failure to sell Belmont real estate he had subdivided for the owner. I suspect the bank’s fortune, and Mr. Oliver’s too, was greatly harmed by the Great Quake in April 1906. Enjoy. John
WANT A BANK IN PESCADERO
Success of Halfmoon Bay Institution Stirs Residents of a Rival Suburb
STOCK IS SUBSCRIBED
Concern Which Has a Capital of $50,000 Will Be Ready
for Business in Few Days
Special Dispatch to Th« Call.
PESCADERO. Aug. 16. — The success which has attended the efforts
of the people of Half moon Bay to establish a bank in their community
has stimulated residents here to emulate the example of their neighbors,
and on August 25 the West Coast Bank and Trust Company will open for business. The new institution has been promoted and financed by D. R. Oliver. The capital stock has been placed at $50,000. of which $25,000 has been paid up. Approximately fifty people here have subscribed for the stock. The new bank will open for commercial  business exclusively, but later will establish a department for savings.”

Comments off

John Vonderlin: When the pork tasted like strawberries…

Story by John Vonderlin

Email John: benloudman@sbcglobal.net

Hi June,

This lighthearted article appeared in the June 14th, 1887, issue of the “Sacramento Daily Union,” and added one more “Claim To Fame,” to Pescadero’s already impressive list. Enjoy. John
Strawberry fed Pork.— From H. B. Pilkington, who has just returned from Pescadero, we learn of a decidedly new phase of the development of our G.C. (Probably George Carter, a local correspondent) It is well known that on the plateaus at the top of the cliffs, which border most of the coast from Point New Year to Pescadero. there grow quantities of a delicate wild strawberry, known as the Beach strawberry, because the sturdy little plant pushes its way even down into the sand along the beach. The fruit is large in size and delicious in flavor, and this year the crop is so enormous that droves of hogs have been turned into these unique seaside pastures, and with all the gusto of sybarites are fattening themselves upon the luscious dainties. Illinois boasts of her “corn-fed pork.” but she will have to take a back seat now in favor of California’s new dainty, ” strawberry-fed pork.”  1887

Comments off

John Vonderlin: Freak of Nature or Mini Wonder?

Story by John Vonderlin

Email John: benloudman@sbcglobal.net

Hi June,
Though the headline labeled this a “Freak of Nature,” I like to think of such things as mini-wonders, a less negative appellation.  What caused it and is it contagious?, are usually the first two things I wonder, but in this case it was, “I wonder where it is now?”  I would have loved to have seen this work of pareidolic art, even though it was enhanced by a carver, rather then a pefectly natural wonder.
The name Nye is vaguely familiar in regards to Pescadero, but I can’t remember anything further at this time. For now it will have to remain one more minor, vanished oddity of the Coastside, home of so many others. This was in the July 3rd, 1890, issue of “The San Francisco Call.” Enjoy. John
A Freak of Nature.
J. R. Nye of 9 Rausch street has mounted and polished and exhibited yesterday a most curious freak of nature. The same is a trunk of an orange tree, grown in Pescadero and ending in a most singular tangle of twisted and gnarled roots, grown into each other or hanging. These branches assumed various shapes of human limbs or animal forms, the effect of which has been heightened by carving. On the roots were also swells or prolongations in forms of a tortoise, a fish, a snake’s head, the body of a lizard, a fox’s head, etc., whose outlines of course have been made truer by the carver’s knife. The base of the trunk took the lines of a head and bearded face, nature’s work upon which has also been rounded.

Comments off

John Vonderlin: The Pescadero Tragedy (7)

Story by John Vonderlin

Email John: benloudman@sbcglobal.net

Hi June,
The indignation meetings had stirred the local folks up, they had rearrested the defendants, Kinsey, et al, and people were demanding a new trial. The next court business came two weeks later when the case went before a Grand Jury as described in this article from November 29th, 1873 issue of”The Daily Alta,”
“THE PESCADERO TRAGEDY
CASE BROUGHT BEFORE JUDGE WHEELER FOR REVISION
The Pescadero Tragedy, which has been the subject of so much comment, not merely because of the killing of one of the parties, but also by reason of the farce enacted at the trial before Justice Walch (sic), came up before the Nineteenth District Court, yesterday, for a review of the testimony taken before Walch, on a writ of habeas corpus, issued by the Supreme Court. San Mateo appears to be at present sadly in need of judges. Justice Fox, of Redwood City, is disqualified to hear the case, because he assisted in the prosecution in the first trial. The County Judge is absent, the District Judge is ill, and the prosecution refuses to let Justice Walch try his hand again. The difficulty occurred between Alexander McClean, William Dow, Captain Kenzie, (sic) and wife, George Green and Harvey Green, The latter was killed.
McClean and Dow are the only two parties not out on bail, and they are anxious for a new trial. The machinery for the law in San Mateo county being in an unmovable condition, application was made to the Supreme Court for a writ of habeas corpus to bring the prisoners before the Nineteeth District Court for a review of the testimony and a decision thereon.
John Reynolds, of San Mateo, represented the defendants, and the People were represented by District Attorney Nutting and C. N. Fox. It appearing that the testimony, which is voluminous, is not transcribed from the shorthand notes, and that the Grand Jury of San Mateo County will be in session the week from Monday next, the Court declined to interfere, as nothing could be gained by the petitioners if he were to take up the case . He denied the application, and the prisoners were remanded to the custody of the sheriff to await the action of the Grand Jury.”
They were indicted and just two months later an article in the  ”Sacramento Daily Union,” from the January 28, 1874, issue read:  “San Francisco 27th,  In the Twelfth District Court to-day the trial of Kinsey and his wife, the two McCleans, and W. Dow for the murder of Harvey Green, at Pescadero, was resumed. Fox, of San Mateo, appeared on behalf of the people, and is now making the opening speech, stating the circumstances of the homicide. Reynolds and Campbell appear for the prisoners. A large crowd of people are in attendance.”
A week later it was the defense’s turn and as reported in the “Sacramento Daily Union’s,” February 6th, 1874, issue:
“The counsel for the defendants in the Kinsey murder case opened argument this morning in the Twelfth District Court. They will argue on the theory of self-defense, and defensive of the property of Kinsey against deceased Harvey Green and his brother.”
By the next day, it was over and the ”Sacramento Daily Union,” reported in the February 7th, 1874 issue:  “San Francisco February 6th, The trial of Captain Kinsey and his wife, W. Dow and J. and Michael McClean. for the murder of Harvey Green, at Pescadero, last November, was concluded in the Twelfth District Court this afternoon. The jury, after an absence of an hour and a half, returned a verdict of guilty of manslaughter against all defendants. Sentence on the 24th inst. (February)”
convictions for All. Case Closed? Not yet. For just two months later an appeal for a new trial was made as detailed in the May 9th, 1874 issue of “The Daily Alta.”
“THE PESCADERO TRAGEDY
The argument of counsel on motion for a new trial in the murder case of Charles Kinsey and others found guilty of manslaughter in the killing of Harvey Green was concluded on Tuesday afternoon, and yesterday Judge Sharpstein passed upon it. He granted the defendants a new trial, on the ground that a good deal of the testimony admitted was irrelevant; and ought not have been admitted, and the proper question to have gone to the jury was, “Who commenced the struggle and first drew a deadly weapon?” The defendants were released on $5,000 bail.”
A week later, a hung jury caused the prosecutors to throw up their hands and throw in the towel, blood-soaked or not, as reported in an article in the ”Sacramento Daily Union’s” May 18, 1874, issue:
“It is believed that, as the jury on the trial of Kinsey, Dow and McLane (sic) for the murder of Harvey Green, failed to agree on a verdict, a “nolle prosequi” will be entered in the case.”
“Nolle prosequi”is a legal term meaning the prosecution will not continue prosecution in the case. The defendants are released, not to be retired unless new evidence appears. And so it seems this sad case came to a close, at least in itscriminal considerations.
What happened, thereafter, to the cast of characters of this tragedy, from the two week old son of Harvey Green to the McCleans, I can’t say. But, the final fate of the instigator, Captain Kinsey, was partially revealed in an article from twenty years later, that appeared in  the August 6th, 1896, issue of ”The San Francisco Call,” and headlined a small story with:
“SUDDEN DEATH AT SAN JOSE
Captain Charles Kinsey Passes Away and Papers Worth a Fortune are Found in His Trunk
San Jose, Cal, August 5th, Captain Charles Kinsey, a veteran of the late war, died suddenly last evening at the Jefferson Hotel of heart disease. He was a native of Germany and 80 years of age. He served with distinction as a captain in the War and was a member of the Grand Army. He had been a resident of the coast for about twelve years, during which time he resided at Hayward’s, Pescadero and Saratoga. He came to this city about six months ago.
In Kinsey’s trunk were papers showing he was  possessed of property worth $40,000. About $15,000 of his estate consists of cash and in bank in this city and San Francisco, and the rest is in notes and mortgages.
But little is known of Captain Kinsey in this city. He has a daughter, Mrs. Victoria Goldmerstein, in New York City, who has been telegraphed to regarding the disposition of the body.”

Twenty years had passed and the notoriety of the Green murder had obviously faded. But, given the pathos of Mr. Kinsey dying alone, in a hotel room, with a suitcase of money, but with no one around to even claim the body, it looks like he was still paying his karmic debts. Enjoy. John

Comments off

John Vonderlin: Kinsey-Green Murder Case: A Shocking Verdict (6)

Story by John Vonderlin

Email John: benloudman@sbcglobal.net

Hi June,
Five days later, on November 19th, 1873, an article appeared in “The Daily Alta,” headlined, “The Pescadero Murder, The Prisoners Discharged–Killing Held to Be Justified.” This shocking decision in the Harvey Green murder case and the town of Pescadero’s reaction to it, was in the article’s text as follows:
Redwood November 18th.—The examination of the Pescadero murder case was concluded last evening. The Justice reserved his decision until this morning, at 9 o’clock, at which hour he, after a few remarks by way of justifying his actions, dismissed the prisoners, who, with the exception of Mr. Kensey, (sic) returned by the stages to Pescadero.
THE POINTS OF THE DEFENCE (Sic)
The Counsel for the defence (sic) held in their argument that they were justified in what they were charged with, and not to blame for the serious results that occurred. The Judge evidently agreed with them in the point made and gave his decision in accordance with this view.
INDIGNATION OF THE PEOPLE
As soon as the decision was known around town, a free discussion was indulged in, and a very marked disapprobation of the Judge’s actions is general in town.
AN INDIGNATION MEETING
At a large and enthusiastic indignation meeting here to-night, the following resolutions were unanimously adopted.
ASTONISHMENT AND INDIGNATION
Resolved, by the people of Redwood City in public meeting assembled, that it is with astonishment and indignation that we have learned of the action of Justice Walsh in discharging the prisoners in the case of People versus Kinsey and others. The case has attracted  public attention to a large degree, and we have watched the testimony and proceedings with no interest other then a desire that  justice should be done, and from the evidence in the case we feel confident that as far as the action of the magistrate could accomplish that result
THE ENDS OF JUSTICE HAVE NEVER BEEN DEFEATED
By the discharge of the prisoners without putting them upon their trial
Resolved, that in our judgment such a result could not have been reached except through
GROSS IGNORANCE
Stupidity, or the undue influence of others,
JUSTICE WALSH REQUESTED TO RESIGN
Resolved, That the Magistrate who for any cause commits so great an outrage against justice and good government, is unworthy of the position, and we now request him to resign his office as Justice of Peace of this township.
ANOTHER TRIAL DEMANDED
Resolved, That the parties should be rearrested and brought to a fair and impartial trial.
Signed,
A. Teague, Curtis Baird, Samuel Bean, Committee
INDIGNATION MEETING IN PESCADERO
8:45 P.M. —We have just learned an indignation meeting  has been held this evening in Pescadero. Resolutions were adopted, giving the Kensey (sic) party twenty-four hours to leave town.
THE KENSEY PARTY REARRESTED
Sheriff Edgar telegraphs that he has rearrested them and he starts for this place in the morning.
Continued in Part 7

Comments off

John Vonderlin: The Kinsey-Green Murder Case (5)

Story by John Vonderlin

Email John (benloudman@sbcglobal.net)

AFTERNOON SESSION
On the court reassembling, the cross-examination of John Green renewed. My brother was not at the house the night before the murder; he lived a mile from my house; he leaves a wife and two children; one a year old, the other two weeks; had been talking to Quinn (a neighbor) frequently about taking possession of the house; old man Quinn, I think, was present at the Friday night occurrence; one of the neighbors said to me before Monday, Nov. 3rd, that we should have gone in the house when my family returned from Illinois; do not know that I declared my intentions to any one that I would take possession of the house before Monday; when the Kinsey party came, on Friday, there were at my house, my brother Harvey, my son George, Thomas Johnson, John Warner, Alfred Melville, John Quinn, wife and daughters; only considered my brother, son, and Johnson, a man in my employ, to consist of my party; the others came there only of their own will; do not know if any of them were armed; all the men were in the yard a few feet from me when I spoke to Mrs. Kinsey at the gate; do not know who entered the house first; after the gate was opened, Kinsey’s teamster picked up Mrs. Kinsey when she fell, that was why I thought he was going to shoot me. I thought he had something in his hand; and I looked, then drew a small pistol from my pocket; took my pistol out because I thought Mrs. Kinsey was going to shoot me over the gate. She was desperate, and said
I AM AS READY TO DIE AS YOU ARE
and am going to take possession of this property. I was at the gate when the first shots were fired, Mrs. Kinsey was being raised from the ground; she looked at the firing and remarked, “Good, good,” and was then dragged in the wagon. After my brother was killed, Dow and the two McLean brothers rushed for the house; saw Alex. McClean go in the house about the time the pistols were fired; saw a man shooting at my son George, who was at the north end of the house, I had a four shooter that night, tried to fire all the shots, but don’t know whether I did or not, saw Knowles, the officer, in the house after the shooting.
Re-Direct
Don’t know whose team it was that brought the Kinsey party to the ground. No objection was made to me going in the house on Monday by the Brashear family, no force was used to get in; Mrs. Brashear said she was glad to get away; that she felt she had no business there; saw Brashear going away from his house when we started; on reflection, I do not think Quinn was mixed up in the fight, but was out at the gate at the start of the shooting. Have been in the habit of carrying a pistol for about a year. Mrs. Brashear and four young children were at the house when I got there Monday; expected but little resistance from the children; my son was armed on Friday night.
John Warner was next sworn. His testimony continued that of the preceding witness, in the main acts. He also testified positively that Dow fired the shot that killed Green.
R. Knowles testified to the main points that occurred during the fight; he could not say positively as to who killed Green; he was considerably excited, and got out of the way of the shots as soon as he could so.
The case will be resumed on Friday.
Continued in Part 6

Comments off

John Vonderlin: 1870s Pescadero Murder (4)

Story by John Vonderlin

Email John (benloudman@sbcglobal.net)

Hi June,
John Green’s testimony was hard to follow, but the Cross-examination is worse. I’m assuming these are just scribbled notes by the correspondent. Enjoy. John
CROSS EXAMINATION
Two steps and a half lead to the house; from the ground are twelve to fifteen inches; was told, on Friday, during the day, that trouble was brewing; Coleman Brashear told me of it before 12 o’clock; I suspected trouble before that; I moved into the house on Monday, Nov. 3rd.; that evening two men came to the house and asked for Brashear; he went out and had a talk with them; he came back and told Harvey or my son, that Kinsey had sent the two men up to help Brashear move out of the house; I told Brashear, Kinsey should do his own fighting; I went to the house at 10 A.M.; found Mrs. Brashear and some children; Brashear came in during the afternoon; passed the time of day with him; he said he had a sore leg; never told him I intended to come there; Brashear moved into the house September 8th, 1st (1st instant = this year) I went there on Moday (sic) Nov. 3rd, with my brother, son, teamster and my wife; we were not all armed, myself and brother were armed, my brother had his shotgun, as he spoke in the morning of hunting quail; two or three days afterward said to Brashear that I intended to lease the place; he said he had a lease from Kinsey; told him I would not recognize the Kinsey lease; Brashear said he did not care if he had a lease from me or Kinsey, so long as he was paid for his work; I told him I would lease it for the most money; he said he would consider the matter; Brashear’s family remained until Friday; his goods were moved to Pescadero by my brother’s team; the order for moving the furniture was given by Brashear Friday morning; before Brashear started away he said there would be some trouble; asked him if he had a lease from Kinsey; he said, no, that he would get it that night. I told my brother about it, and he went to see Brashear; the neighbors, generally, advised me to take possession of the house. I had lived in the house for sixteen years, until a year ago, in November.
Counsel for defence (sic) asked witness whether the witness had not given a deed of the property to Kinsey. The prosecution admitted from Nevember 1872, to Novembe 3, 1873, Kinsey, by his tenants, was in possession of the property.
Counsel for defence (sic) then desired to go into the history of the deeds passed between the parties, which was objected to by the prosecution and sustained by the court.
A COOL REQUEST DENIED
Counsel for defence (sic) requested the privilege of the Sheriff to take Mr. Kinsey and his wife to the hotel to take dinner. The District Attorney objected to the prisoner’s being removed from the jail; he wanted no such precedent.The court sustained the objection. A recess was then taken. Continued in Part 5

Comments off

John Vonderlin: 1873: Pescadero Murders, Parts 2 & 3

Story by John Vonderlin

Email John: benloudman@sbcglobal.net

Hi June,

This newspaper article from the November 14th, 1873, issue of “The Daily Alta,” is about the in-progress trial of those accused of the murder of Harvey Green. It is interesting that the trial was well underway within a week of the time the killing occurred. Considering there had been talk of a lynching in Pescadero, a quick trial was probably a good idea. This is the beginning of the reporting on the trial:
THE PESCADERO MURDER
Fatal Termination of a Land Dispute. Six Persons Charged With Murder — Preliminary Examination In Progress.
The town of Pescadero was thrown into a state of excitement on Friday by the report of a murder about a mile and a half south from the town, growing out of a disputed possession or one hundred and sixty acres of land, claimed by John B. Green and Charles Kinsey, and for which civil suits are pending in the Twelfth District Court in San Mateo. The facts, in the case are somewhat mixed, though the majority of the people in Pescadero believe that the property belongs to Green, though he conveyed the property to Kinsey, who paid as consideration some lands in Illinois. Green went to Illinois to take possession of the property conveyed to him, and to his surprise, says that he found the property was mortgaged and a portion was in Kinsey’s brother’s name. Green returned with his family and an investigation resulted the finding among the records that the property had been declared a homestead by Green in Santa Cruz county, when Pescadero was a portion of that county. It appears, that in the transfer of the property to Kinsey, no mention was made of the homestead, and Mrs. Green’s signature was not obtained, as was necessary to pass the title. Kinsey, however, was in possession of the property tor 1 year, and Green, acting under the advice of neigh- bors, conc!uded to take peaceable posession of the property, on the ground that he had received no consideration for it. This led to the fatal affray four days and a haIf after Green re-entered on the land, and for which six persons are now charged with murder.
The persons under arrest are: Charles Kinsey, Mr. Nancy Elizabeth Kinsey. Alexander McLean, Michael McLean, Wm. Dow and W. F. Beam. Charles Kinsey is a grey-headed man, about sixty years of age, and has resided in Pescadero since 1864, keeping a store; was at one time Postmaster, and the last few years has been keeping the Lincoln House. He is a man of a positive temper and only a fair social standing in the community. Mrs Kinsey is a woman upward of forty years of age, strong-minded, and of a determined character. She has a daughter, by her first husband, seventeen years of age. Dow is also a married man; the other three are single, and all are working men.
THE PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION
Of the accused was commenced in Redwood City yesterday. The People were represented by District Attorney W. M. Nutting. Charles N. and George W. Fox, and Messrs. J. Reynolds and H. Kincaid appear for the defendants before Justice of the Peace Walsh, before whom the examination is pending.
About thirty witnesses have been subpoenaed, most of them for the prosecutors, and it may take several days to get through with the case. Mrs. Kinsey sat beside her counsel, dressed in deep bases, and did not appear to be at all affected by the very serious charges against her. She listens attentively to the testimony detailed by the witnesses, and frequently suggests questions to her counsel. The second witness examined was a brother of the deceased, Harvey Green, in which the principal points of the case for the people are developed.
Dr. J. J. Clark was the first witness called, and testifed that on Friday night last, he was called to attend to Harvey Green at…
Pascadaro; found hIL. ly-ng a abort di.lance from the hona,, dead; tat post mortem ex* i*iastion showed that iitsitli was canoed ty a gunshot around in the neck, the jugular vein ia BMW, the bullet entered the r <Lt etd. snd p»aKd through 10 the Bats] also found a wound in the hip. the wound In the neck was hi rassi 1 lij fatal; Gr.-.o’i
(When I run into a passage like this, where the OCR (or OCM, Optical Character Misrecognition, in this case) is this wildly inaccurate I get slowed down in transcribing the articles, but get a small chuckle out of the results. The passage seemingly about BMWs, canoes and Bats should read:
…Pescadero found him lying  a short distance from the house, dead; a post mortem examination showed his death had been caused by a gunshot wound to the neck, the jugular vein was severed, the bullet entered the right side and passed through to the left; also found a wound in the hip; the wound in the neck was necessarily fatal; Green’s body was four to six feet; hardly think the body had not been moved after being shot down; (sic?) could not say from which direction the bullet came; the man was lying on his back; the wound in the neck was made while the man was living.
JOHN R. GREEN
was next called and testified: I reside at Pescadero, am a farmer, was there on Nov. 7th, at my house,  a mile and a half south of Pescadero, at eight o’clock that night, when John Warner came to my house and warned me a party was organizing at Pescadero, headed by William Dow, with twenty or thirty persons, who were coming to take possession of the property, or they would have it burn to ashes. I did not credit the report at first and said I would not think Lowe (sic) would do such a thing. My brother Harvey was in the house, my son John, Warner, myself and two others and my family . Soon after Mr. Knowles came (the Deputy Sheriff and Justice of the Peace) up. I went out to see him; he asked me if I knew a party was being organized to come to my house; told him I had heard of it; my brother and Warner then rode towards Pescadero to see if it was so; and in a half an hour they returned and said they had heard a wagon coming up the road; I said, I will go down to the gate and meet them and see if I can reason with them to prevent any rash act; the wagon came along with Mrs. Kinsey, Dave McClean, and Beam; Knowles spoke to Mrs. Kinsey at the wagon, she, however, went
DOWN TO THE GATE and said, “I will go into that house .” I told her she would not go in, as that was not her house; she replied, “If I can’t get in through the gate, I’ll get in over the fence.” Dow said he had rented the property and he was going to take it; Knowles asked him if he had any papers and Dow said yes, he and the McLeans had a lease and they were going to keep it; the lease was shown to Knowles; Mrs. Kinsey again attempted to go through; told her I would not let her; she put her hand on the gate and then Dow and McClean jerked the gate from me; I pushed Mrs. Kinsey and she fell on her back; a man was standing behind her, whom I took to be the teamster, and he picked her up; I looked for a moment and thought he might shoot me
THEN HEARD VOLLEYS AT THE HOUSE
Mrs. Kinsey cried, “Good!” “Good!” The teamster pulled her to the wagon; and I went to the house, now pistol shots exchanged freely; went to the left and looked in the crowd for my brother and saw him go apparently to the door; I saw him stagger back and he fell, I went to go to him; and when near him, shots came whinning by me, and I rushed out to see if I could see the man who was shooting at me; one ball glanced by my cheek; I was shot in the hand and my gun was shot out of my right hand; when I got back to the door, the firing had ceased; my first impulse was to jump over the fence, and in passing the house, my son stopped me and said Harvey was shot; I went to my brother, put my hand near his heart, and saw he was dead; I saw Alexander MacLane (sic) pass in through the door, and think he shot at Mr. Johnson; saw three men afterward in the house; my brother was dead and I gave up; when the gate was first jerked from me, Dow said, “The ball is open.” He went in, followed by McLane, my brother was on the left of me, and then ran to the house; I stood there for a moment to see if there would be any shooting, and then I ran to the house as fast as I could get there; when I got there the men were in the house and about there; my brother was standing near the door; and I saw two men shooting; one of the MacLanes (sic)was standing on the left side of the door with a pistol aimed at my son, he then turned to my brother, he then turned to my brother, and soon after I saw him stagger and fall, one of the men shooting was Alex MacLane; 9sic) my brother was facing the door as I was about ready to go in the house; think he fell from the shot he received in the neck; noticed my brother particularly, because I knew he would stay by the house if he could; I was 4 feet from my brother when he fell; could not say whoch man shot my brother.
CROSS EXAMINATION  Continued in Part 4

Comments off